Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
CLASSICS

In Richmond Heights, Pointer’s Pizza offers New York-style pies, fast delivery and $500 for finishing a monster pizza

Did you know that one of St. Louis’ claims to fame is actually a food challenge?

Longtime Richmond Heights pizzeria Pointer’s Pizza offers the Pointersaurus: A 28-inch, 10 pound pizza that lives up to its dinosaur-themed name. The rules are pretty simple: Two people must consume the entire Pointersaurus in one hour; The Pointersaurus has to have two meat toppings or four vegetable toppings; and winners who finish eating the Pointersaurus receive a $500 cash prize. 

The Pointersaurus has been attempted over 8,000 times in the 28 years Pointer’s has offered the challenge, attracting people from all over the globe. Only 54 people have ever successfully completed the challenge, meaning the success rate is less than 1%. It’s about time for another champion – there hasn’t been a winner since 2016. 

The Pointersaurus has been featured on the Travel Channel’s “Top Ten Places to Pig Out” and the Food Network’s “Top Five Pizzas with Pizazz.” However, Pointer’s Pizza is known for something else around St. Louis: its speed. 

Pointer's exterior

Pointer's Pizza is located in Richmond Heights. 

“When somebody calls in an order to pick it up, we will have it ready in 10 minutes,” owner Dave Hughes says. “People are surprised about that. Most other places will say 30 to 45 minutes.”

Hughes also guarantees 30 minute delivery. On a Friday night, you’ll find three people manning the kitchen and four busy delivering. Pointer’s operates in a three-mile radius, which includes two major universities (Washington University and Fontbonne University) and three hospitals (Barnes-Jewish, St. Louis Children’s and St. Mary’s), which means their pies are in high demand. 

Pointer’s specializes in New York-style pizza, made with freshly hand-tossed dough and mozzarella cheese. These highlights differentiate Pointer’s from the many St. Louis-style pizza joints in the area, which Hughes says Washington University students – many of whom hail from the East Coast – greatly appreciate.

“They’re all about it because that’s what they’re used to,” Hughes says. 

Pointer’s menu includes several different pizza sizes along with pasta, sandwiches, salads and, of course, the Pointersaurus. The Pointersaurus is popular even when it’s not being ordered as a challenge – the monstrously big pizza can feed up to twenty people, making it a great party meal. 

“I never get tired of hearing, ‘That is the biggest pizza I’ve ever seen,’” Hughes says. “You can’t not have fun with it.”

Pointer's Pizza, 1023 S. Big Bend Blvd., Richmond Heights, Missouri, 314.644.2000, pointersdelivery.com

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Charlotte Renner is the associate editor at Feast Magazine. She loves reading, going to concerts and spending time outdoors, especially with her fiancé and their two dogs.

Related to this story

Most Popular