Myster Shopper Aged Goat Cheese

Capriole's Sofia, Cypress Grove's Humboldt Fog, Hervé Mons' Ovalie Cendrée

I obsessively handpick the ingredients for this column, but this month, I did something unheard of: I placed myself in the hands of an experienced local cheesemonger. She led me to a selection of aged bloomy-rind goat cheeses coated with ash, and I fell. Hard.

What is it? I enjoy fresh chèvre as much as the next person, but it can be chalky, tangy and limited in terms of flavor. Goat milk can be used to make a range of cheese styles, like the three bloomy rinds featured here. I tested Cypress Grove's Humboldt Fog from California, Capriole's Sofia from Indiana and Hervé Mons' Ovalie Cendrée from France for this recipe; for a local option, try Angel Food or Little Bloom on the Prairie from Prairie Fruits Farm & Creamery in Champaign, Illinois. Visually, they're stunning: The cratered rinds give way to smooth inner pastes that straddle liquid and solid.

What do I do with it? Each of these aged goat cheeses offer a clean and mellow alternative to fresh chèvre, with complex flavor that’s softly assertive and never overpowering; all three feature hints of lemon, mushroom and grass. Charcuterie platters are a given, but summer is upon us: Amp up your burgers (turkey or beef) with melted slabs of aged bloomy-rind goat cheese and a peppery green like arugula or cress. Crumble it into green salads with summer berries, toasted nuts, a sturdy grain like farro and a simple vinaigrette. These aged goat cheeses also invigorate a classic pasta primavera.

Subscribe to Breaking News

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Shannon Weber is the creator, author and photographer behind the award-winning, and her work has appeared on websites such as Bon Appétit, Serious Eats and America’s Test Kitchen.

More Mystery Shopper articles.